Do You Really Need Surgery for a Rotator Cuff Tear?

Written by
Jon McQuistan, DPT
Published on
July 28, 2025

Rotator cuff injuries are one of the most common reasons people walk into my clinic—whether it’s from a weekend of pickleball, years of overhead work, or just one awkward lift. One of the first questions I get is: “Do I need surgery?”

The truth is, many rotator cuff issues don’t require going under the knife. Physical therapy often works just as well—especially for partial tears and tendonitis—and can even help prepare your shoulder if surgery does become necessary later on.

Conservative Care vs. Surgery – What the Research Says

Research shows that physical therapy is a very effective first-line approach. For partial-thickness tears, rehab often provides pain relief and improved function comparable to surgery, especially in adults over 50. Even with small to medium full-thickness tears, starting with therapy first is still recommended.

A five-year study found that people who chose surgery for small to medium tears had slightly better long-term strength and pain scores compared to those who only did therapy. But here’s the interesting part: about 75% of people who tried therapy first never needed surgery at all.

When I explain this to my patients, I tell them that PT is like taking the scenic route to recovery. It’s safer, it teaches you how to move better, and it builds strength and stability—things that can help protect your shoulder for years to come.

What Does a Physical Therapy Session Look Like?

When you come in for a shoulder session with me, we start by finding the root of the problem—figuring out which motions or positions trigger pain and what’s really limiting your shoulder.

A typical session is 45–60 minutes and may include:

  • Manual therapy: I’ll spend time working on the soft tissue around your shoulder and shoulder blade. Sometimes we do joint mobilizations or trigger point release to loosen up stiff or irritated tissues.
  • Guided mobility drills: We might use a dowel, band, or pulley to help move your shoulder through pain-free range of motion.
  • Strengthening work: This is the fun part! I’ll have you do exercises that target your rotator cuff and scapular stabilizers. Things like banded external rotations, prone “Y” and “T” lifts, or serratus punches (great for shoulder blade control).
  • Education: We talk about what you should and shouldn’t do between visits, and I’ll send you home with a simple plan you can follow to keep making progress.

I also like to keep things practical. If you’re a golfer, tennis player, or weightlifter, I’ll show you how to modify your activity so you can keep moving instead of sitting on the sidelines.

The Exercises We Use

Rotator cuff rehab isn’t about lifting heavy weights or pushing through pain—it’s about smart, controlled movements that wake up and strengthen the smaller stabilizing muscles in your shoulder.

Early on, we focus on exercises like cane-assisted lifts, and scapular squeezes to restore mobility without aggravating the tissue. Once your pain calms down, we shift into strengthening mode.

Some of my go-to exercises include:

  • Sidelying external rotations (a powerhouse for targeting the cuff).
  • Resistance band exercises for external and internal rotation.
  • Prone Y’s, T’s, and W’s to strengthen the shoulder blade and upper back.
  • Wall slides and serratus punches for better overhead motion and stability.

Later, we progress to more functional moves—plank variations, light overhead presses, and even medicine ball work if your sport requires it.

Why PT Is Worth Trying First

Most people are surprised at how quickly they start to feel better once they move the right way and strengthen the right muscles. With consistent therapy and home exercises, many patients can avoid surgery completely. And even if surgery becomes necessary down the line, doing PT beforehand sets you up for a smoother recovery.

Thinking about starting shoulder rehab? My goal is to keep you active in the things you love—whether that’s golf, tennis, lifting, or just being able to reach overhead without pain. If you’re dealing with shoulder pain or a diagnosed rotator cuff tear, reach out. We can create a plan that fits your life and gets you moving better without jumping straight to surgery.

Ready to Stop Guessing and Start Moving?

Start with a phone consult to discuss your goals. We'll build a plan of care around what you need and help you get back to doing what you love.